Skip to content

Bonnet Cleaning vs. Carpet Extraction: A Comparison

It can be difficult to keep up with the ever-changing trends and technologies in facility maintenance. What works best for one facility may not necessarily work best for another, making it difficult to pick the right technique or tool without doing your research. When it comes to the upkeep of your commercial carpets, there are two options: bonnet carpet cleaning and extraction cleaning. Here we will explore what makes these two approaches different from one another so you can make an informed decision that will benefit both your budget and your long-term upkeep goals.

Carpet Cleaning

Bonnet Cleaning

Bonnet cleaning is a method that uses a buffer machine with a pad soaked in a cleaning solution to clean the top layer of the carpet. The machine spins the pad, which absorbs dirt and grime from the carpet fibers, leaving them looking clean. Commercial janitorial companies often utilize this technique due to its efficiency in cleaning high-traffic areas. This can be a great choice for maintaining the cleanliness of your carpets, especially in commercial settings with heavy foot traffic. It can also be done more frequently since the carpet is only dampened while extraction can be done only when necessary. Bonnet cleaning also uses fewer chemicals and little water, making it an eco-friendlier option than carpet extraction. However, if the carpet is already quite dirty, bonnet cleaning may not be able to remove the deep stains and dirt, and a deep cleaning method like carpet extraction may be necessary.

While bonnet cleaning is relatively quick and affordable, it is not as effective as carpet extraction in removing deep stains and dirt from the carpet fibers. This method only cleans the top layer of the carpet, leaving dirt and stains still ingrained in the depths of the carpet. This can lead to a buildup of grime over time, making the carpet look dingy and dull. Additionally, bonnet cleaning can be too harsh on delicate carpet fibers, causing damage and fraying.


Carpet Extraction

Carpet extraction, or deep cleaning, uses powerful machinery to force hot water and cleaning solution deep into the carpet. The water breaks down dirt and grime, which is then extracted using a powerful vacuum. This method is highly effective for removing deep stains and dirt and is usually recommended for heavy-duty cleaning tasks. It also extends the lifespan of carpets by eliminating the dirt and debris that cause wear and tear. Additionally, regular carpet extraction improves indoor air quality by reducing allergens and dust. It also makes your carpets look and smell better, creating a more comfortable and inviting environment for customers and employees alike.

Carpet extraction can be expensive and time-consuming, with carpets taking several hours to dry completely. This can be a problem for businesses that need to access the area immediately after cleaning. Additionally, if the cleaning solution is not properly rinsed, it can leave residue on the carpet that can attract dirt and debris, causing it to get dirty faster. Despite these drawbacks, commercial carpet cleaning is still an effective method for maintaining the longevity and appearance of your carpets.

McLemore opts for the carpet extraction method, which is highly effective. While bonnet cleaning is a more budget-friendly option, it may not completely eliminate all dirt and stains from your carpets as it only addresses the surface layer. In contrast, carpet extraction offers a more comprehensive clean by delving deep into the carpet's fibers to extract dirt and stains. Although it may come at a higher cost, it delivers a more powerful and durable outcome.


All in all, deciding between bonnet cleaning and carpet extraction for your specific needs is a matter of careful consideration. Ultimately, depending on your budget, desired result, and long-term goals, it might be worthwhile to consider investing in deep carpet cleaning over bonnet cleaning if you need to go the extra mile. Whatever your carpet cleaning needs may be, our experts here at McLemore are always here to help. We offer eco-friendly products and services tailored to meet the unique needs of each customer we serve. To learn more about what we offer and how we can help restore the life of your carpets, contact us today!


Leave a Comment